Tuesday, March 18, 2014

BAR EXAM 2013 RESULTS

Congratulations to the UP College of Law! :D And to everyone who passed!
UP's stats
Batch 2013: 82.5%
Overall Passing Rate: 79.40% (Includes those who are not taking the Bar for the 1st time)
The Top 10 passers are as follows:
1. Nielson PanganUniversity of the Philippines85.8%
2. Mark Xavier D. Oyales
Dianna Louise R. Wilwayco
University of the Philippines85.45%
Ateneo de Manila85.45%
3. Rudy OrteaUniversity of Batangas84.2%
4. Eden Catherine MopiaUniversity of the Philippines84.05%
5. Tercel Maria Mercado-GephartUniversity of San Carlos83.9%
6. Manuel SarausadUniversity of Cebu83.8%
7. Katrine SuyatSan Beda College Manila83.75%
8. Michael Tiu JrUniversity of the Philippines83.70%
9. Marjorie Ivory FulguerasAteneo de Manila83.65%
10. Cyril ArnestoUniversity of the Philippines83.60%
The Supreme Court lowered the passing grade to 73%, exercising its discretion to make adjustments in the rules. SC Associate Justice Arturo Brion, Chairperson of the 2013 Bar Examinations, said that if the passing rate remained at 75%, only 694 could have passed.

Here is the complete list of passers:
1. ABAD, Anna Fe L
2. ABAD, Katrina Nessa M
3. ABAD, Philip L
4. ABALOS, Mermalyn Hannah C
5. ABANDO, Laura Jean L
6. ABARENTOS, April Wye M
7. ABELLA, Fritzie D
8. ABENOJA, Hazel Angeline Q
9. ABLAN, Ronie T
10. ABLOG, Maychelle S
11. ABRAGAN, John Bryan S
12. ABRENICA, Reyben B
13. ACAY, Jodea Brendalyn R
14. ACEBU, Carlos D
15. ACEVEDA, Arlene C
16. ACHA, Mae Ann S
17. ADAO, Ma. Alice E
18. ADARNA, Ernest G
19. ADRID, Michael Angelo D
20. ADUNA, Fritzie Jane A
21. ADVINCULA, Paula Elize A
22. AFAGA, Johnber B
23. AGOCOY, Joycie M
24. AGRA, Joel C
25. AGUILA, Erasto Miguel D
26. AGUSTIN, Redentor M
27. ALAMPAY, Beatrice S
28. ALAO, Lemeregin S
29. ALBAN, Norlee C
30. ALBANO, Errol L
31. ALBARECE, Rhona B
32. ALBAÑA, Angeli P
33. ALBERTO, Julianne S
34. ALCALA, Marijo V
35. ALCANTARA, Nequito Alejandro B
36. ALCARAZ, Jesse S
37. ALCORDO, Nikki T
38. ALDANA, Daryl C
39. ALEGADO-REBADULLA, Mary Rose B
40. ALFONSO, Krissel E
41. ALI, Michael Mito-on J
42. ALIH, Abdel Aziz T
43. ALMORA, Aileen T
44. ALONZO, Jason L
45. ALONZO, Randolph F
46. ALTEZ, Czarina May C
47. ALTONAGA, Vedalyn M
48. ALVARADO, Sarita G
49. AMBATALI, Eliezer P
50. AMBRONA, Venus B
51. AMOR, Maria Auxilliadora Libertine C
52. AMPATUAN, Bai Saudia Shahara B
53. ANACAN, Realyn R
54. ANANORIA, Catherine A
55. ANARNA, Alston Kevin A
56. ANBOCHI, Francesco Benzon P
57. ANCHETA, Aster Mae A
58. ANDES, Jay M
59. ANG, Hannah Stephanie Y
60. ANG, Jennelyn Charme M
61. ANG, Nathalie S
62. ANGA-ANGAN, Mary Grace D
63. ANGANGCO, Bernadette Marie G
64. ANGELES, Darwin P
65. ANGELES, Diana Rose M
66. ANGLUBEN, Van Homer M
67. ANTENERO, Vicvie D
68. ANTEOLA, Garizaldy H
69. ANTONIO, Angela A
70. ANTONIO, Laila R
71. ANTONIO, Regatta Marie A
72. APADA, Jemar B
73. APDUA, Arnold A
74. APOSTOL, Kristienne O
75. AQUINO, Lex T
76. AQUINO, Terese Ray Anne O
77. AQUINO, III, Amado P
78. ARAGONES, Christine Marie D
79. ARANAS, David Anthony B
80. ARANETA, Yasmin Therese P
81. ARAVILLA, Jose Felipe P
82. ARAÑA, Roel B
83. ARAÑEZ, Charo P
84. ARCE, IV, Marcelino C
85. ARDINA, Sheena Lorraine O
86. ARELLANO, Zoraida P
87. ARENAS, Dianne Katrine S
88. ARNESTO, Cyril G
89. ARRIOLA, Ethel Joy F
90. ASONG, J.p. Leo F
91. ASTURIAS, Jose Manuel V
92. ASUNCION, Archie Edsel C
93. ATIENZA, Leandro Rodel V
94. ATILANO, Patrick Jason P
95. ATIS, Jainito-roi C
96. AURE, Lelila G
97. AUSTRIA, Ramil G
98. AVELINO, Ma. Vanni Fe C
99. AVESTRUZ, Kirk D
100. AXALAN, Mikko Angela C
101. AYCO, Karina Kirstie Paola R
102. AZIS, Anisah C
103. BACAL, Christie Joy G
104. BACANGAN, Almary A
105. BACOMO, Devie J
106. BADI, Carla Mae E
107. BADILLES, Cielo Maris S
108. BAGA, Noel M
109. BAGO, Horace J
110. BAGUISI, Alain B
111. BAHJIN, Tishreen I
112. BAJAO, Hannahbee Grace R
113. BALA, Carlo D
114. BALAHADIA, Jesa Anne Carla E
115. BALAMBAN, Keith Wally Y
116. BALANI, Roshni V
117. BALAO, Bernadette Faustine C
118. BALAQUIAO, Eleanor N
119. BALBOA, Jasper C
120. BALDOS, Jennifer C
121. BALIAT, Aurea Belen P
122. BALICOCO, Waynie Mae P
123. BALIGOD, Maria Nadine Concepcion V
124. BALINO, Kristy Jane M
125. BALLEBER, JR., Alfredo L
126. BALTERO, Kenneth Brian D
127. BANZON, Mark Lawrence V
128. BANZUELA, Analyn F
129. BAQUIRAN-LASAM, Czaren L
130. BARAOIDAN, Kimberly Joy L
131. BARATA, Edmund N
132. BARBA, Diana Gay T
133. BARRIENTOS, Carlo Gerard DC
134. BARRIENTOS, Michael Oliver P
135. BARTOLOME, Jemimah Estelle T
136. BARUC, Ace Daryl D
137. BASCO, Shayne Anne R
138. BASCON, Dexter George P
139. BASCUÑA, Ross Raphael T
140. BATALLA, Christian Jesse G
141. BATIMANA, Joanness S
142. BATTAD, Geoanne Christi D
143. BAUL, Magher S
144. BAUTISTA, Alvin A
145. BAUTISTA, Jonathan Allen S
146. BAUTISTA, Manilyn R
147. BAUTISTA, Maria Francesca V
148. BAUTISTA, Vera Marie H
149. BAYALAN, Alfierri E
150. BAYAN, Nerissa Q
151. BAYANI, Madeleine F
152. BAYNOSA, Freddie Ii H
153. BEADO, JR., Antonio B
154. BEDAR, Hanifah D
155. BEJAR, Kristel Ann-marie A
156. BELDEROL, Katleya Kate M
157. BELEN, Genevieve D
158. BELLO, Maria Remedios L
159. BELLOSILLO, Nikki Magdalene A
160. BELTRAN, Richard Henrick I
161. BENTREZ-BANCILO, Joshelle Ruth C
162. BERGONIA, Sherly Ann R
163. BERNABE, Jebert Benedict J
164. BERNARDINO, Antonio Jose P
165. BERNARDINO, Crisela L
166. BISANG, Juliett Isabel P
167. BLACK, Dominique Deborah D
168. BLASCO, Leana Mae M
169. BLEZA, Maria Keala Mae M
170. BOISER, Marisol M
171. BOJA, Marilda J
172. BOLANDO, Reagan A
173. BOLANIO, Jesrel E
174. BOLIVAR, Joy B
175. BOLLER, Jian Paulo P
176. BOLOS, Marie Nickie H
177. BONILLA, JR., Wilfredo T
178. BONO, Camille E
179. BONOAN, April Jade A
180. BORIGAS, Mickel M
181. BORRACHO, Merachelle R
182. BORRES, Kristoffer Alexis N
183. BRAÑA, Arleigh Joyce A
184. BRILLANTES, Francis James G
185. BRIONES, Jan Derric P
186. BUADO, Maria Edsie V
187. BUCOY, Julio Cristo PG
188. BUENAVENTURA, Kenneth A
189. BUGTAS, Chika E
190. BULIYAT-BENCIO, Celeste Roxanne
191. BUNAG, Jan Nicklaus S
192. BUNANIG-ODON, Kathryn Joy I
193. BUSANGILAN, Mira Ciele S
194. BUSTAMANTE, Blesie May P
195. CABAHUG, Christian Marko D
196. CABALUNA, Sedfrey L
197. CABANILLA, Ana Flouressa Y
198. CABATU, JR., Rodolfo S
199. CABRAL, Arthur Jake E
200. CABUNGCAL, Ana Pamela G
201. CABURNAY, Arjane V
202. CADAG, Ma. Carmen A
203. CAGAMPAN, Joyce Anne O
204. CAINDAY, Kathlyn Jane B
205. CALABOCAL, Erickson L
206. CALDERON, Alex D
207. CALDERON, Francesca Isabelle G
208. CALDERON, Ma. Sherlyn D
209. CALIMBAS, Monica D
210. CAMARILLO, Robert August C
211. CANAPI, Cheryl P
212. CANCINO, Krisyl M
213. CANTO, Frances Ianna S
214. CANTOS, Cathrine P
215. CAPACIO, Jane Angel V
216. CAPACIO-LIRIO, Denise Fe R
217. CAPILI, Van Joseph F
218. CAPIRAL, Joshua Paul C
219. CAPUNGCOL, Edelyn L
220. CAPUNO, Maria Evangeline B
221. CARBONELL, Wilfred M
222. CARCEDO, Harvey L
223. CARDENAS, Mark Lester D
224. CARPIO, Peter Lloyd D
225. CARPIO, Phillip Nelson F
226. CARRASCO, Margeline T
227. CASARES, Madonna Lyn E
228. CASAS, Neil Jason T
229. CASIMIRO, Gizela Grace D
230. CASIMIRO, Lara Mae D
231. CASIPIT, Marq Jonathan C
232. CASIPONG, Alfred S
233. CASPE, Lourdes Anifel B
234. CASTAÑEDA, Harmon V
235. CASTAÑEDA, Kimberly L
236. CASTILLO, Cherry Mae M
237. CASTILLO, David Anastacio G
238. CASTILLO, Jether Jireh A
239. CASTILLO, Norberto V
240. CASTILLO, JR., Cenon C
241. CASTILLON, David F
242. CASTOLO, Camille Maria L
243. CASTRO, Alexandra C
244. CASTRO, Jose Julius R
245. CASTRO, Josefa Gertrudis D
246. CASTRO, Patricia Marie Frances D
247. CATABONA, Mark Arthur M
248. CAYETANO, Jeanelyn D
249. CAYETANO, Karen R
250. CAYETANO-ABDUHALIM, Revelyn C
251. CAÑAZARES-MINDALANO, Annabelle B
252. CAÑETE, Charnem B
253. CEBRIAN, Kristian Oliver P
254. CELDRAN, Leo Mario C
255. CELESTINO, Mark Brian R
256. CEREZO, Arianne Y
257. CERVANIA, Krystle K
258. CHATTO, II, Efren Dominique M
259. CHAVEZ, Anna Fatima R
260. CHAVEZ, Margarita Luisa F
261. CHIL-ANG, Marichu C
262. CHING, Cherry Christine S
263. CHIO, Judy-mae G
264. CHIONG, Kester Orville T
265. CHUA, Antonio Francis G
266. CHUA, Christine Jean O
267. CHUA, Jingle L
268. CHUA, Jordan Mae T
269. CIMAGALA, Alexis N
270. COLES, Nat King C
271. COLOBONG, Moises Ronette C
272. COLOMA, John Patrick S
273. COMPUESTO, Jiselle B
274. COMSTI, Gianna Maria C
275. CONCHA, Kathleen Kaye G
276. CONCHA, Kristoffer Francis Jacob C
277. CONDEZA, Ernel C
278. CONGSON, Blessy Marie Angela C
279. CONTI, Maria Kristina C
280. CORALDE, Maria Aimer A
281. COROLLO, Graziella D
282. CORONACION, Maricel C
283. CORONEL, Jerome I
284. CORPUZ, Habeas M
285. CORPUZ, Mercy C
286. CORTEZ, Ailyn L
287. CORTINA, Anezka Danett G
288. CORTON, Gerald Peter P
289. CORUÑA, II, Isagani C
290. CRESPO, Joseph Kahlil P
291. CRISOLOGO, Frederick William D
292. CRISOLOGO, Nico Carlo M
293. CRUZ, Dan Joseph T
294. CRUZ, Dandy L
295. CRUZ, Esther Rhoda S
296. CRUZ, Michael Joseph D
297. CRUZ, II, Benjamin Jeremias B
298. CRUZ-CAÑETE, Jill Cindy L
299. CU, Roxanne F
300. CUE, Katrina Ayn Ayza F
301. CUREG, Ryan P
302. CUSI, Erika Estel G
303. CUSTODIO, James Corwin S
304. DABA, Robert James T
305. DABALOS, Nerissa Ann P
306. DABAO, JR., Philip Gerard P
307. DACULUG, Roque D
308. DADIVAS, Christine P
309. DADULLA, JR., Ramon J
310. DAGALANGIT, Rahabansa L
311. DAMASCO, Fidela S
312. DAMASING, Glenn D
313. DASAYON, Climark D
314. DAVID, Kristin Kay S
315. DAVID, Manuel Jeffrey N
316. DAVID, Patricia S
317. DE CASTRO, Diana Jean C
318. DE GUZMAN, Elaine P
319. DE GUZMAN, Francis Ron C
320. DE GUZMAN, Gabriel Paolo L
321. DE GUZMAN, Jhoanna Mariekar V
322. DE JESUS, Gianna Corrine D
323. DE JESUS, Joeben T
324. DE JESUS, Joseph Georg Michael D
325. DE LA CRUZ, Clarisse Ann Marie M
326. DE LA CRUZ, Maria Cecilia A
327. DE LA CRUZ, Rosella Jan G
328. DE LA PAZ, Lauren Anne M
329. DE LEON, Jose Miguel B
330. DE LOS SANTOS, Dave Bernar L
331. DE MESA, Jena Christine E
332. DE PAZ, Marvin Lester N
333. DE RIVERA, Kristienne Kamille E
334. DE TORRES, Marcella Alita D
335. DE VERA, Elaine L
336. DE VERA, Ina Beatriz R
337. DE VILLA, Macario M
338. DE ZUZUARREGUI, Anthony R
339. DECLARO, Ruth Agnes D
340. DEDALA, Francis Ysmael M
341. DEJARESCO, Antonio Marlon Eric I
342. DEL ROSARIO, Dan Mitchel C
343. DEL ROSARIO, Jaime P
344. DEL ROSARIO, Margarita Isidora S
345. DEL ROSARIO, Maureen Grace J
346. DELA CRUZ, Alexis Ian P
347. DELA CRUZ, Catherine G
348. DELA CRUZ, Keefe Eldrik A
349. DELA CRUZ, Marie Angeli V
350. DELA CRUZ, Maureen G
351. DELA PASION, John Paul A
352. DELA ROSA, Catherine D
353. DELA TORRE, Ivy Lou S
354. DELEÑA, Ma. Blesilda B
355. DELIMA, Josie W
356. DELIS, Ma. Phoebe G
357. DELORINO, Rene A
358. DELOS REYES, Roxanne Katrin M
359. DELOS SANTOS, Sherwin R
360. DENATE, Martin Crisostomo Q
361. DIASANTA, Mel Jun A
362. DIAZ, Magelli Anne DL
363. DIAZ, Rona April D
364. DICHOSO, Joseph M
365. DINIAY, JR., Dionisio C
366. DINOY, Keel Achernar R
367. DIOQUINO, Arwin F
368. DIWAS, Kristofferson D
369. DIWAS, Rhenan G
370. DIÑOZO, Ramona R
371. DOCTOR, Erwin Jake C
372. DOCTOR, Maan Vanessa L
373. DOMINGO, James Cristopher D
374. DOMINGO, Miguel B
375. DONSOL, Ma. Carolina P
376. DOROTAN, Maria Gabriela C
377. DOYAOEN, Annette L
378. DUEÑAS, Joan Roshen M
379. DULAWAN, Vivian M
380. DULNUAN, Ruby Anne L
381. DUMAGAN, Menchie V
382. DUMALAG-BORONG, Jennife DP
383. DUMLAO, Rhondee E
384. DUQUE, Bernice Michelle N
385. DUROPAN, Ramie Felmon P
386. DY, Diana C
387. DY, Eli Daryl S
388. EBREO, Alvin H
389. ECHAUS, Adrian Jude G
390. EDRADA, Andrew Ian P
391. ELEAZAR, Jonna Lou A
392. ELMAN, Jenika H
393. EMBAY, Christine Grace P
394. EMPALMADO-LIMBARO, Gwendolyn R
395. ENAD, Ann Marie M
396. ENAD, Wendel M
397. ENARIO-VIDALLON, Vivian C
398. ENRILE, II, William R
399. ENRIQUEZ, Rowena S
400. ENTERINA, Ian M
401. ESCOLANO, Richard Dale V
402. ESCOTO, Sharon R
403. ESCUETA, Hana Kamille A
404. ESPANILLO, JR., Domingo M
405. ESPENILLA, Mark Anthony G
406. ESPERAS, Erika Mariz V
407. ESPINA, Hazel D
408. ESPINO, Donato V
409. ESPINO, Ric James G
410. ESTACIO, Zachary J
411. ESTEMBER, Philip Louie H
412. ESTERNON, Karen Jenny E
413. ESTOPERES, Mary Antonette A
414. ESTRELLA, Maricor D
415. EUGENIO, Rodelyn Gay G
416. EUROPA, Rose Celine R
417. EVANGELISTA, Jose Paolo M
418. EXIOMO, Jeffrey P
419. EXTRA, Sheyna Marie M
420. EZPELETA, Candy U
421. FABELLA, Joanne Marie C
422. FABRIGAS, Delfin, Jr. S
423. FABRO, Howard B
424. FAJARDO, Diana S
425. FAJARDO-ONG, Alma D
426. FANTILANAN, Jahziel P
427. FELONGCO, Emerson J
428. FERAREN, Fermin Maylene B
429. FERMIN, Doreen Grace R
430. FERNANDEZ, Angelica P
431. FERNANDEZ, Catherine M
432. FERNANDEZ, Charity T
433. FERNANDEZ, Trisha Isabelle F
434. FERNANDO, Francis Paul N
435. FERNANDO, Ronald Thomas L
436. FERONEL, Leonardo A
437. FERRER, Luzell Z
438. FLORES, Michael Angelo V
439. FONACIER, Karla Flor D
440. FORTEA, Natassia L
441. FOSTER, Analiza G
442. FOSTER, Kimberly D
443. FRANCISCO, Justin James D
444. FRINAL, Nelyn B
445. FULGUERAS, Joel E
446. FULGUERAS, Marjorie Ivory S
447. FUMERA, Robert G
448. GABALDA, Rusella G
449. GABUNAS, Divine Grace B
450. GABUYA, Ryan R
451. GACUTAN, Michael Aaron P
452. GALA, Steven Michael D
453. GALAGALA, Kim P
454. GALIMBA, Jordan R
455. GALING-LUNA, Moera Joy N
456. GAMBOA, Avril Elaine U
457. GAMBOA-CASTRO, Cherry Grace Z
458. GAMIAO, Leo Anthony M
459. GAMONNAC, Abigail D
460. GANDO, Ace Arvin V
461. GANIR, Leigh Angelie A
462. GARAY, Stephanie G
463. GARCIA, Carlos P
464. GARCIA, Charlene Lorena D
465. GARCIA, Jasyrr J
466. GARCIA, Jemimah Grace N
467. GARCIA, Maria Ara H
468. GARCIA, Marvin P
469. GARCIA, Zharmai C
470. GARCIA-DELA CRUZ, Anna Katrina L
471. GARCIANO, Maria Corazon D
472. GARDE, John Edmar G
473. GASATAYA, Jorelyne L
474. GASPAR, Ma. Teresita J
475. GATUS, Maria Roldeliza L
476. GAVINO, Jeriel T
477. GAVINO, Romir David B
478. GAVIOLA, Alan Byrne S
479. GAYAGAY, Michelle B
480. GAYDA, Philip Jason G
481. GENERAL, Smith P
482. GENESELA, Jozzyl T
483. GERONIMO, Armida A
484. GESMUNDO, Franchesca Abigail C
485. GESTOPA, Gevina V
486. GILDO, Casilda P
487. GO, Dennis O
488. GO, Faith P
489. GO, Jan Claude Patrick P
490. GO, III, Joseph M
491. GOLONG, Kenneth M
492. GOMEZ, Jhoann D
493. GOMEZ, Ma. Eliza Christine C
494. GONZAGA, Maria Jonika Y
495. GONZALES, Andrea Monica V
496. GOTOHIO, Stanley L
497. GRAN, Majken Anika S
498. GRAPILON, Raul S
499. GUERRERO, Mia Rustiel M
500. GUEVARA, Juliet Marie M
501. GUEVARRA, Joan Carla V
502. GUIAO, Abraham P
503. GUIDORIAGAO, Erma Marie R
504. GUILING-MATANOG, Ayesha Hania B
505. GUILLEN, Angelo Karlo T
506. GUNAY, Fredelyn S
507. GUTIERREZ, Emmanuel B
508. GUTIERREZ, Myron Dei A
509. GUZMAN, Angela Y
510. HABACON, George Matthew T
511. HADUCA, Marvin Edgar R
512. HAJIM, Al-zhoheir H
513. HALILI, Ma. Fe M
514. HAN, Stefano Dong Chul C
515. HANS, Jaimmie C
516. HERNAL, Gian Carla V
517. HERNANDEZ, Christopher M
518. HIDALGO, Phoebe Corazon C
519. HIDLAO, Hadji Hrothgar O
520. HIPOLITO, JR., Cesar B
521. HONORARIO, Christopher B
522. HUMIWAT, Gemale P
523. ICASIANO, Charles David A
524. ILAGAN, Cindy A
525. ILAGAN, Roju Sandino A
526. IMMOLIAP, Kendall Pung-ao T
527. IMPERIAL, Nd P
528. INOT, Leofel F
529. INOTURAN, Sophia P
530. INTONG, Iris Joy Consolasion C
531. IPIO, Raymund L
532. ISLES, Vincent S
533. ITO, Anwar M
534. JACINTO, Markova I
535. JACOB, Vanessa D
536. JACOSALEM, Jot P
537. JAMACA-UNO, Jedyl E
538. JAMORA, Raymond Francis Maria C
539. JANGAD, Nowyn-hope A
540. JASARENO, Ramil F
541. JAVIER, Jonathan A
542. JIMENO, JR., Cecilio M
543. JO, Jonathan C
544. JOCSON, Jenefer G
545. JONTILA, Jansen I
546. JOSE, Jefferson D
547. JUADA, Kristine Anne P
548. JUICO, A. Rafael C
549. JULIAN, Clarissa Anne Q
550. JULKIPLI, Mohammad Al-amin M
551. JUMALON, James A
552. JUNASA, Djoanivie Jomare A
553. JUNIO, Isabela Rose Jane B
554. JUNIO, Mary Joy P
555. JURADO, III, Cicero D
556. KAW, Alison Katrina Georgina T
557. KEH, Katherine C
558. KEMPIS, Kenneth M
559. KHAN, Donelle T
560. KHO, Sophia M
561. KHOLOMA, Sharon P
562. KING, Jeremy P
563. KING, Karl Edward C
564. KINTANAR, Krisza Joy P
565. KWOK, Maris Donna G
566. LABAJOSA, Michael John B
567. LACSON, Audrey Violet A
568. LACUNA, Marionne Rosabell R
569. LADEZA, Roel John M
570. LAGARDE, Mikaela Francine D
571. LAGASCA, Marianne Franchesca Therese S
572. LAIÑO, Arfil Joy G
573. LALIA, Yashneira A
574. LAMAC, Rodwil L
575. LAMAN, Ralph James G
576. LAMBINO-MALIMBAN, Kaye Coleen D
577. LAMBOSO, Ilda Marie E
578. LAMIGO, Kahlil L
579. LAMPA, Tristan D
580. LAMUG, Jackie Lou D
581. LANETE, Jesi Howard S
582. LAPERAL, Fatima P
583. LAPEÑA, Rheina B
584. LAPINIG, Jade A
585. LAPITAN, Erwin E
586. LASAM, Norman Clarence T
587. LATORRE, Charlaine E
588. LAUANG, Edzon Cristian C
589. LAUDENCIA, Karla Mae R
590. LAUREL, Michaela Victoria L
591. LAURON, Diana Margaret C
592. LAURON, Salud Beberly F
593. LAVA, Mari Joie C
594. LAVADIA, Eric Benjamin D
595. LAVADIA, Michael John T
596. LAYNO, Ian Abelle P
597. LAYSON, Gian Carlo R
598. LAZA, Bernadette B
599. LAZO, Leo Albert A
600. LEAÑO, Roniel V
601. LEDDA, III, Jose C
602. LEE, Anna Olivia S
603. LEE, Jassen Ralph A
604. LEE, Jude Z
605. LEE, Lara Camille A
606. LEGASPI, Ma. Theresa A
607. LEGASPI, Portia Fidelis C
608. LENDIO, Nathaniel V
609. LEONADOR, Rowel Jake L
610. LEYBAG, Jason C
611. LEYES, Hanna M
612. LIM, Frances Dyan T
613. LIM, Jan Alexander E
614. LIM, Jane Kathyrine B
615. LIM, Maridez C
616. LIM, Rahlee Jane B
617. LIM, JR., Angel A
618. LIMCOLIOC, Louie Mark R
619. LINGBAWAN, Baby Jacklyn D
620. LINOG, Hannah Khiarra C
621. LIPAT, Irene Ann Y
622. LIQUIGAN, Christoffer Allan A
623. LISBO, Eric A
624. LIWANAG, Fem Christine M
625. LLOREN, Warren Marc P
626. LO, Justine Andrew C
627. LONGAYAN-TABILIN, Maricar T
628. LONGNO, Christine N
629. LONTOC, Mary Catherine B
630. LOON, Jose Martin A
631. LOOT, Jemirose R
632. LOPEZ, Gene Edward DC
633. LOPEZ, Nelson D
634. LOPEZ, Niño Jubilee S
635. LORENZO, Norman N
636. LORETCHA, Jane B
637. LORICO, Jennilene V
638. LORICO, Michael Joseph J
639. LOYOLA, Emmanuel D
640. LOYOLA, Joseph Nelson Q
641. LOYOLA, Maria Daisy M
642. LOZADA, Stefanie Noelle A
643. LUCENARIO, Marien Kathrine A
644. LUCERO, Ian Kenneth B
645. LUCERO, Lucie Antonette D
646. LUGTU, Juliben L
647. LUMANGLAS, Crisalyn B
648. LUMANTA, Jan Louenn L
649. LUNA, Ginber M
650. MAAMO, Anthony L
651. MABBUN, Ma. Antonette M
652. MABINI, Cyra M
653. MACAINDIG, Datumama M
654. MACALINO, Ralph Vincent S
655. MACAPAGAL, Ryann S
656. MACAPAGAL, Stephanie Luzette M
657. MACARAEG, Tyrus Joshua M
658. MACARAMBON, Muhammad Ali M
659. MACATANGAY, Sherleen Lourds R
660. MACLA, Jamail Lunar G
661. MADRIÑAN, John Andrew M
662. MAGABILEN, Darlene Marie S
663. MAGNO-GUYGUYON, Candice K
664. MAGRATA, Marielle M
665. MAGSAMBOL, Iderlyn P
666. MALABANAN, Arianne C
667. MALABANAN, Marie Krizel P
668. MALABANAN, JR., Arnaldo C
669. MALAMUG, Jerry Anton Paolo U
670. MALVAR, Michael Andrew G
671. MAMARIL, Charise P
672. MAMENTA, Maricris R
673. MANA-AY, Grace N
674. MANANGKIL, Jill B
675. MANDOCDOC, Dan Kevin C
676. MANGABAN, Ma. Lourena M
677. MANGAHAS, Gabrielle Ruth D
678. MANGCO, Carlos Joseph Frederick
679. MANGUBAT, Christian Paul N
680. MANIGBAS, Anne Maureen B
681. MANIQUIS, Katrina G
682. MANLANGIT, Donna Patricia C
683. MANLICLIC, Eleni Francesca G
684. MANOTOC, Ferdinand Richard Michael M
685. MANUBAG, Reman V
686. MANUEL, Leylann Generoso R
687. MANUEL, Melvin L
688. MANZANARES, JR., William P
689. MANZANO, Katrina Ross P
690. MAPUTI, Julius Art P
691. MARALIT, Catherine Angela V
692. MARANGIT, Zarith Sofiah G
693. MARANTE, IV, Hermenegildo P
694. MARCAIDA, Ramon Carlo F
695. MARGALLO, Ralph Lawrence M
696. MARI, Marjorie H
697. MARISTELA, Marvyn L
698. MARISTELA, Melissa Fina U
699. MARIÑO, Yehushelline Joy L
700. MARQUEZ, Fellain Ann P
701. MARQUEZ, Jadelee I
702. MARTINEZ, Rodulfo Jose R
703. MARTINEZ, Theena C
704. MASACAYAN, Earl Louie M
705. MASCENON, JR., Ernesto Mario S
706. MATEO, Armi Liza M
707. MAUHAY, Mary Giselle R
708. MAURO, Claire Marie B
709. MAÑO, Chris Jark Ace M
710. MEDALLE, Irma Mari P
711. MELCHOR, Bettina R
712. MENCIAS, Rowena Mae N
713. MENDEZ, Ivan Viktor N
714. MENDIGUARIN, Eman Michael M
715. MENDIGUARIN, Genevieve S
716. MENDOZA, Allan Duane A
717. MENDOZA, Anna Loraine M
718. MENDOZA, Beverly I
719. MENDOZA, Mara Khrisna Charmina F
720. MENDOZA, Miguel Antonio L
721. MENDOZA-OBUMANI, Jesme Donna R
722. MERCADO, Noel Patrick Y
723. MERCADO-GEPHART, Tercel Maria G
724. MERCENE, Annaliza P
725. MERCURIO, Walesa J
726. MIEL, Allan Arnel D
727. MIGUEL, John Evan C
728. MIJARES, Kristine P
729. MILAOR, Rose Andrea V
730. MILLAN, Princess Mae A
731. MILLARE, Loreta Fairie Ann R
732. MINGUEZ, Al Jason V
733. MIRAL, Mercy Joy R
734. MISLANG, JR., Armando F
735. MISOLA, Vanessa Y
736. MIÑOZA, Ma. Golda Gigi G
737. MO, Sophia C
738. MOLO, Jade Paulo T
739. MONJE, Monna Lissa C
740. MONOTEN, Edgar S
741. MONTESCO, Aldrin R
742. MOPIA, Eden Catherine B
743. MORADA, Julienne Marie A
744. MORATO, April Rose N
745. MORAÑA, Hansel P
746. MOSQUITE, Michael M
747. MOSTOLES, Sherwin T
748. MOYA, Ann Faustine T
749. MUARIP, Myra C
750. MUNDIN, Maria Cristina T
751. MUÑOZ, Roniel D
752. NABONG, Rose Vida D
753. NACINO, Racquel H
754. NACIONAL, II, Rene Q
755. NACUA, Bernadine R
756. NADAL, Janice G
757. NAGA, John Henry D
758. NALLIW, Joan Sheelah O
759. NARVAEZ, Stephanie Marie L
760. NAVA, Anna Rose M
761. NAVARRA, Ellie Chris C
762. NAVARRA, Janelle Aquilina Marie
763. NEBRIDA, Rosario Joy F
764. NELLAS, JR., Alberto P
765. NEPOMUCENO, Juan Paolo M
766. NERY, Anna Suzanne C
767. NG, Cyris Ann A
768. NGO, Mary Grace M
769. NGOSLAB, Donna K
770. NIETO, Paolo D
771. NILLAMA, Kirwen B
772. NILLAMA, Mae Grace June C
773. NOLASCO, Raizulli M
774. NOMBRADO, Israel C
775. NUDALO, Grace A
776. NUEZ, Miguel Lorenzo Y
777. NUQUE, Reymond G
778. NUÑEZ, Samantha Louise J
779. OAMINAL, Althea Isobel F
780. OBBUS, Fe V
781. OBNIMAGA-MIRAL, Maria Janel S
782. OCAMPO, Josephine Gabrielle Melissa L
783. OCANA, III, Norman Roland E
784. OFO-OB, Seichi E
785. OLANDESCA, Gabriel Guy P
786. OLFINDO, Ryan Paul N
787. OLIVA, Ma. Richelle Q
788. OLIVA, Regal M
789. OLVIDA, Mark Anthony C
790. ONG, Mark Stephen K
791. ONG, Matthew Aaron D
792. ORESTE, Mary B
793. ORTEA, Rudy V
794. ORTEGA, Marvin G
795. ORTILE, Neil G
796. OSMEÑA, Ruhjen S
797. OVIEDO, Jose O
798. OXALES, Glenda G
799. OYALES, Mark Xavier D
800. PAAT, Erwin A
801. PABLICO, Christopher Jhundi D
802. PABLO-NEPOMUCENO, Czarina J
803. PACABIS, Ryan T
804. PACHECO, Aira P
805. PAGALA, Rosemarie D
806. PAGDONSOLAN, O'jay A
807. PAGUICAN, Joshua D
808. PAGULAYAN, JR., Alipio C
809. PALAY, Mabelle Grace A
810. PALLUGNA, Gregorio Miguel H
811. PALMA, Andrew M
812. PALMA, Maria Racquel Carmeli T
813. PALMARES, Louie Mae P
814. PALOMAR, Annabelle Therese G
815. PALPAGAN, Marc Ivan D
816. PAMBID, Karlon V
817. PANDAN, Ramon Antonio D
818. PANGAN, Nielson G
819. PANGANIBAN, Haydee Gretchen G
820. PANGANIBAN, Rodelyn L
821. PANGHULAN, Gerwin A
822. PANIAGUA, Carlo James C
823. PANLILIO, Victor Christopher B
824. PANONG, Hazel Joy P
825. PANTALEON, Sencia L
826. PANUGALING, Rey Cris A
827. PARADO, Mariel Jances Nhayin D
828. PARAS, Mary Kristine Joy S
829. PARAS, Rex L
830. PARAÑAL, Jonah Paul G
831. PARCIA, Teresa Rose D
832. PARCO, John Joseph S
833. PARLADE, Lalaine Mae C
834. PASCUA, Marie Antoinette V
835. PASCUA, Ruby Anne B
836. PASCUA, Suzanne G
837. PASCUAL, Jim S
838. PASCUAL-BELLO, Cristine E
839. PASIA, Mon Cristopher B
840. PASQUIL, Cria Marie L
841. PATAGAN, Gerille Hope E
842. PATALINGHUG, Eligene B
843. PAUMAR, Alberto S
844. PE, Laurie A
845. PE, Lorene A
846. PE BENITO, Armi Christie C
847. PEDRO, Kirk Mathew R
848. PELAYO, Jannefer Jannice G
849. PENDATUN, Sittie Amirah K
850. PENDATUN, JR., Datu Nasser A
851. PERALTA, Anna Margarita C
852. PERALTA, Eric Paul D
853. PERALTA, Lorena R
854. PERDIGUERRA, Toni Marie L
855. PEREGRINA, Johann Chairo E
856. PEREZ, Dikko Jay C
857. PESISANO, Wincerbogne L
858. PEÑA, Irwin L
859. PEÑARANDA, Jon Dominic P
860. PFLEIDER, JR., Rodolfo D
861. PICHAY, Olivia Emmanuelle A
862. PICO, Nathan Michael O
863. PIELAGO, Juan Carlo O
864. PILAPIL, Julius P
865. PILOTON, Edison R
866. PINEDA, Edelise D
867. PINLAC, Sergio Ildefonso Felipe O
868. PINOON, Lorevill S
869. POMOY, Rashel Ann C
870. PORQUEZ, Jonalyn G
871. PORTUGALIZA, Michel B
872. PRECIOSO, Dexter B
873. PRINCIPE, Ruskin G
874. PUA, JR., Greg G
875. PULIDO, Karina N
876. PULIDO, Paula Editha I
877. PULTA, Ma. Victoria B
878. QUE, Kathrina Sheena Marie L
879. QUEBEC, Aldrin Jude M
880. QUERIJERO, Elizabeth Anne M
881. QUEROBINES, Rowel A
882. QUIBRAL, Regie Matet C
883. QUILANG-SALVIEJO, Marites M
884. QUINTO, Jacqueline Ann R
885. RABAGO-AGUSTIN, Fairy Faith B
886. RABAJANTE, Maria Diory F
887. RABAYA, Gerwin Ryan L
888. RABE, Cheryl Grace M
889. RABENA, Gerald F
890. RABONZA, Maria Christina C
891. RADA, Mayeth C
892. RAMIRO, Roberto Miguel D
893. RAMOS, Renee Camille V
894. RAMOS, Rizal Disraeli S
895. RAMOS, Vince Paolo L
896. RAYCO, Georgeanna Rainbow S
897. RAYMUNDO, Joshua S
898. RAYPON, Ma. Althea Rholene J
899. RAZON, Zenaida R
900. RAÑA, Rhone A
901. RAÑOLA, Mary Ann I
902. REAS, Ma. Ruby Ann P
903. REBAÑO, Ma. Patricia F
904. RECIO, Gelina Rose E
905. REDOBLE, Rogelio Benjamin J
906. REGIS, Jasmin Mei C
907. RELUCIO, Rendl James C
908. REMIGIO, Francis Jay E
909. RENALES-LUCERO, Antoniette Maria S
910. RENES, Jan Richard A
911. REVITA, Mariza I
912. REYES, Ana Francessca A
913. REYES, Harly Jayson U
914. REYES, Ma. Christina S
915. REYES, Marie Kristine F
916. REYES, Peter Gian-marc R
917. REYES, Pierre Martin D
918. REYES, Rafaella Carmela P
919. REYES, Raymond C
920. REYES, Romel O
921. REYES, Tristan A
922. REYES, JR., Tito L
923. REYES-VEGA, Patricia B
924. RIGAT, Rose Ann B
925. RIGETS, Robert Edward G
926. RILE, Mary Jane G
927. RILLERA, Christinne Marie A
928. RIVERA, Katrina N
929. RIVERA, Neil Allan D
930. RIVERA, Phillip Raymund S
931. ROBLEDO, JR., Michael A
932. ROBLES, Jannica G
933. ROBLES, Joanna Marie G
934. RODAS, Vincent Abril U
935. RODEL, Salvador S
936. RODRIGUEZ, Anna Katarina B
937. ROJAS, Raisia Mae DV
938. ROLDAN, Joyce Anne C
939. ROLDAN-ADVINCULA, Michelle D
940. ROMAGOS, Lois S
941. ROMAN, Martin Kristoffer F
942. ROMERO, Faith B
943. ROMERO, Marigold D
944. ROPLOC, Salvador F
945. ROSAL, Maria Karla Soleil F
946. ROSALEJOS, Chyrs Anne M
947. ROSALES, Christine Heide A
948. ROSALES, Mary Grace Anne S
949. ROSARIO, Glenys M
950. ROSITO, Rommel R
951. ROXAS, Idesa L
952. RUBIN, Ronald Patrick T
953. RUBINOS, Ronajoy G
954. RUBIO, Mark P
955. RUBLICO, Jan Edgar J
956. RUIZ, Theresa C
957. RUIZO, Liway Czarina S
958. RUIZOL, Mari Joyce R
959. RUZ, Jan Edmond Y
960. SABIO, Rodolfo Apolonio R
961. SACDALAN, Strella Marie G
962. SACRAMENTO, Anne Jaycelle C
963. SACULLES, Myraflor G
964. SADSAD, Kathrina Mishael C
965. SAGARINO, Irvin Z
966. SAGARINO, Rodelynn Rajini A
967. SAGUID, Roel S
968. SALENGA, Jerico D
969. SALOMON, Mark Rossel D
970. SALUNGKIT, Jhunar I
971. SALVADOR, Farina R
972. SALVADOR, Julie Ann C
973. SALVADOR, Lea Diana B
974. SALVATIERRA, Mary Rose B
975. SAMPANG, Canhermi O
976. SAMSON, Dhan Morris M
977. SAMSON, Samantha B
978. SAN JOSE, Warren D
979. SANCHEZ, Malene Jade G
980. SANGUIR, Aileen M
981. SANSON, Rosebell L
982. SANTELLA, Janice J
983. SANTIAGO, Arceelyn J
984. SANTIAGO, Mark Andrew M
985. SANTIAGO, Rita Therese F
986. SANTIAGO, Ronald O
987. SANTILLAN, Steve M
988. SANTIZO, Nicholas C
989. SANTOS, Gail Joseph S
990. SANTOS, Julius Loren C
991. SANTOS, Rio Rose B
992. SANTOS, Sammy Dave A
993. SANTOS, Thomas Angelo A
994. SAPGUIAN, Vicky Louise G
995. SAPIO, Milcah T
996. SARAUSAD, Manuel Elijah J
997. SARIBONG, Tina Marie C
998. SARINES, Agatha Grace A
999. SARMIENTO, Michael Franks T
1000. SARON, Ednalyn R
1001. SARTHOU, JR., Ronald Luke T
1002. SAYSON, Markgregor Edward C
1003. SEGOVIA, Jan Michael K
1004. SERAFICO, Mary Mae Jane A
1005. SERRANO, Janz Hanna Ria N
1006. SEÑA, Andrea Isabel B
1007. SEÑOR, Nes Patrick K
1008. SIAPIAN, Alvin A
1009. SICANGCO, Paulo Alberto T
1010. SICLOT, Haney Lynn G
1011. SILVA, Albert Christian C
1012. SILVA, Julie Ann G
1013. SILVESTRECE, Niño Anthony M
1014. SIO, Nathaniel Eric U
1015. SIPIN, Kristianne Laridor M
1016. SIRIBAN, Victor Andrew A
1017. SISON, Jeniffer P
1018. SISON, Sheila C
1019. SOCIAS, Jairus T
1020. SORIA, Ivy Agatha V
1021. SORIANO, Ivon Francis Y
1022. SOTTO, Jillienne Grace M
1023. SOTTO, Leighton John M
1024. STA. ANA, Marie Micaela T
1025. STO. DOMINGO, Charmaine N
1026. SUAREZ, Andre Anton S
1027. SUAREZ, Maria Socorro D
1028. SUAREZ, Ronald Ryan T
1029. SUBA-RODRIGUEZ, Anne Gillian G
1030. SUING, Ma. Niña Jasmin R
1031. SULIT, Ma. Ricca Pearl S
1032. SULTAN, Val Christian T
1033. SUMAGUI, Ma. Angeles B
1034. SUYAT, Katrine Paula V
1035. SY, Alwyn U
1036. SY, Edson Byron K
1037. SY, Kriselle Samantha D
1038. TABIGNE, Richard D
1039. TABINGAN, Jeona Mae S
1040. TABLADA, Kaven B
1041. TABORA, Jake Rupert T
1042. TAGRA, Earl C
1043. TAGUIAM, Lorraine G
1044. TAJON, Marlowe Doms R
1045. TAJON, Mayvelyn P
1046. TAMAYAO, Michael Jhon M
1047. TAMAYO, Anna Clarife M
1048. TAMBASEN, Alora Mae J
1049. TAMBIAC, Gray S
1050. TAN, Aimee Beryl C
1051. TAN, Franz Kevin R
1052. TAN, Joshua A
1053. TAN, Ma. Donnabel T
1054. TAN, Patrick P
1055. TAN, JR., Gerardo R
1056. TANATE, Marianie C
1057. TANG, Rhomellie B
1058. TANGO, IV, Brian Benson G
1059. TANGOAN, Chris Francis C
1060. TANHUECO, Maria Karrissa A
1061. TAYABAN, Vanessa B
1062. TAYAG, Maria Angeline L
1063. TAÑUTE, Richelle R
1064. TECSON, Jacky Lyn O
1065. TEE, Divine Grace C
1066. TELOG, Thania Marie L
1067. TENORIO, Milmon Bryce C
1068. TENORIO, Regine Amor P
1069. TEPORA, Marian C
1070. TETANGCO, Patrick Arnold P
1071. TEVES, Ma. Cassandra C
1072. THELMO, Marie Angelica M
1073. TIATCO, Misheena Joyce C
1074. TINAPAY, Earl Tristan Ian A
1075. TIU, Alisha S
1076. TIU, Elaine B
1077. TIU, JR., Michael T
1078. TO, Mellisa Joyce Y
1079. TODA, Annalee Joyce C
1080. TOLENTINO, Irish Tom T
1081. TOLENTINO, Joyce Maika J
1082. TOLENTINO, Karissa Faye R
1083. TOLENTINO, Marlene Amparo C
1084. TONGCO, Candice Christine O
1085. TONGSON, JR., Luisito G
1086. TORIO, Cerizar Vicente S
1087. TORRE-RONDEZ, Maria Luisa Cristina K
1088. TORRES, Archiesyl S
1089. TORRES, Jose Carlos S
1090. TORRES, Karen Andrea D
1091. TORRES, Ronald Hallid D
1092. TORRES, JR., Edgar Y
1093. TORRIJOS, Corinna Lorenza T
1094. TORRIJOS, Ma. Mercedes Leanne Antonia B
1095. TORTOLES, Catherine Rose R
1096. TRANGIA-SOLIS, Buena Joy C
1097. TRAVILLA, Cherrel Joy S
1098. TRAZO, Greta Monica D
1099. TRINIDAD, Cherry Lynn M
1100. TRINIDAD, Regina Camille A
1101. TRONO, Gene Mae E
1102. TUASON, Juan Miguel D
1103. TUBIG, George Herbert N
1104. TUGADE, Salvador Andrew S
1105. TUGADI, Wayne A
1106. TULLAO, Fernando R
1107. TUMACDER, Mikhail Maverick P
1108. ULIP, Rhonella L
1109. UMALI, Kristine Camille Y
1110. UMALI, Marie Gene Cecille B
1111. UMEREZ, Enrico L
1112. URANI, Ryan L
1113. URDAS, Krisleen Grace T
1114. USMAN, Maleiha E
1115. USSAM, Reymund Al F
1116. UY, Herazeus Christine Y
1117. UY, Jameson P
1118. UY, Jonathan Buemio
1119. VALBERDE, Jordan Elizabeth C
1120. VALBUENA, Adrian N
1121. VALCOS, Keith Alexandra S
1122. VALDEZ, Jules Boy R
1123. VALENZUELA, Jana Monica Z
1124. VALERIO, Carlo B
1125. VALERIO, Neo Y
1126. VALLEJOS, Virgel Amor O
1127. VALLESTERO, Rizza Joy S
1128. VARGAS, Edgar A
1129. VAÑO, Rhee Christopher C
1130. VELARDE, Patricia C
1131. VELASCO, Raymond Q
1132. VELAYO, Lovely Aissa B
1133. VELOSO, Pinky D
1134. VENDIOLA-CABANILLA, Isiderlyne M
1135. VENERACION, Carmen Cecilia T
1136. VERDEJO, Jonathan N
1137. VERGARA, Marianne T
1138. VICENTE, Glaiza Kaye C
1139. VICENTE, Rowell B
1140. VILLALOBOS, Maria Kamille E
1141. VILLAMOR, Ralph Julious L
1142. VILLANUEVA, Ma. Jade B
1143. VILLANUEVA, Viviene B
1144. VILLAREAL, Jobelle U
1145. VILLARTA, Hannah Joy A
1146. VILLEGAS, Chandine Kaye P
1147. VILLENA, Ezekiel Joshua L
1148. VILLENA, James Ryan B
1149. VINLUAN, Mark C
1150. VIOLA, Stephanie-eden T
1151. VISTA, Ann Margarette C
1152. VIVAR, Clarisse Nicole S
1153. VIVAR, Ma. Theresa Carmina E
1154. WEIGAND, Esther M
1155. WILWAYCO, Dianna Louise R
1156. WONG, Arnel Vincent A
1157. YACAPIN, Myra Vita C
1158. YAN, Veronica Mae C
1159. YANES, Marian R
1160. YANG, Rowena B
1161. YBAÑEZ, Joseph B
1162. YCONG, Mhealler T
1163. YECYEC, Jo Edward F
1164. YPARRAGUIRRE, Robbie James D
1165. YU, Acelynne Joanne O
1166. YUSON, Christian Anthony B
1167. ZAFRA, Jordan G
1168. ZAFRA, IV, Jose P
1169. ZARASPE, Jenn Krystel C
1170. ZATARAIN, Marni Rose D
1171. ZENAROSA, Anna Karenina A
1172. ZULUETA, Isabel S
1173. ZULUETA, Redmond John D
1174. ZUÑIGA, Fatima Eliza O

(SOURCE: RAPPLER)

Monday, March 17, 2014

[Digest] Ortigas vs. FEATI (1979)

ORTIGAS & CO., LIMITED PARTENRSHIP V. FEATI BANK AND TRUST CO. (1979)
 Santos, J.

Facts:
·         Ortigas  & Co., Limited Partnership engaged in real estate business developing and selling lots to the public particularly Highway Hills subdivision along EDSA
·         March 4, 1952 – Augusto Padilla y Angeles and Natividad Angeles entered into separate agreements of sale on installments over Lots 5 and 6 Block 31, Highway Hills
·         July 19, 1962 – Augusto and Natividad transferred their rights and interests in favor of Emma Chavez
o    Transfer contained the following restrictions and stipulations:
§  For residential purposes only
§  All buildings and improvements (except fences) should use strong building material, have modern sanitary installations connected to the public sewer or own septic tank and shall not be more than 2 meters from the boundary lines
·         Resolution 27 – Feb 4, 1960 – reclassified the western part of EDSA (Shaw boulevard to Pasig River) as a commercial and industrial zone
·         Such restrictions were annotated on the TCTs
·         July 23, 1962 - Feati bank bought Lot 5 from Emma Chavez while lot 6 was purchased by Republic Flour Mills


·         May 5, 1963 – Feati Bank began laying foundation and construction of a building for banking purposes on lots 5 and 6
·         Ortigas & Co. Demanded that they comply with the annotated restrictions
·         Feati Bank refused arguing that it was following the zoning regulations
·         Ortigas & Co. filed a case in the lower courts which held that Resolution No. 27 was a valid exercise of police power of the municipality hence the zoning is binding and takes precedence over the annotations in the TCTs because “private interest should bow down to general interest and welfare.”
·         March 2, 1965 – motion for reconsideration by Ortigas & Co. which was denied on March 26, 1965
·         April 2, 1965 Ortigas filed notice of appeal which was given due course on April 14, 1965 hence this case.

Issues:
WON Resolution No. 27 is a valid exercise of police power
WON Resolution No. 27 can nullify or supersede contractual obligations by Feati Bank and Trust Co.

Held:
YES it is a valid exercise police power.
YES it can nullify contractual obligations by Feati with Ortigas & Co.

Ratio:
·         The validity of the resolution was never assailed in the lower courts and can therefore not be raised for the first time on appeal
o    The rule against flip flopping issues and arguments prevents deception in courts
o    Ortigas & Co. also did not dispute the factual findings of the lower court on the validity of the resolution
·         Assuming arguendo it was properly raised the resolution is still valid
o    RA 2264 (Local Autonomy Act) Sec 3 empowers municipalities to adopt zoning and subdivision ordinances or regulations for the municipality
o    The resolution is regulatory measure!
o    RA 2264 Sec 12 à any fair and reasonable doubt as to the existence of the power should be interpreted in favor of the local government and it shall be presumed to exist à this gives more power to LGUs to promote general welfare, economic conditions, social welfare and material progress in their locality
·         The non-impairment clause of contracts is not absolute since it must be reconciled with the legitimate exercise of police power
o    when general welfare and private property rights clash, the former must prevail through police powers of the state
·         Lots 5 and 6 front EDSA and has become surrounded by industrial and commercial complexes
o    Development in the area has resulted in extreme noise and air pollution that is not conducive to health, safety and welfare of the would-be residents à justifies the usage by Feati Bank of the land for more reasonable purposes

Decision: Affirmed

Dissenting: Abad Santos, J.
·         Resolution 27 is valid because it has not yet been struck down but it is not a legitimate exercise of police power because its means (zoning) do not fit with its purpose of general welfare
·         Zoning the area as industrial and commercial will contribute to chaos, frenzy, pollution, noise which suffocate and cause the deterioration of the ecology à Lowers quality of life for residents in Metro Manila



[Digest] Bel-Air Association vs. Intermediate Appellate Court (1989)

BEL-AIR ASSOCIATION V. IAC (1989)
  Sarmiento, J.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Before the Court are six consolidated petitions, docketed as G.R. nos. 71169, 74376, 76394, 78182, 82281 and 60727. The first five petitions for a motion for reconsideration raise the issue of whether Jupiter Street is for the exclusive use of Bel-Air Village residents. Meanwhile, the last petition (G.R. 60727) raises the lone issue of whether or not the Mayor of Makati could have validly opened Jupiter and Orbit Streets to vehicular traffic.

Facts
·         Ayala Corporation (original owner of the property subsequently subdivided as Bel-Air Village) executed a Deed of Donation covering Jupiter and Orbit streets to Bel-Air Village Association (BAVA).
·         Respondents allege that upon instructions of the Mayor of Makati, studies were made by the on the feasibility of opening streets in Bel-Air Village calculated to alleviate traffic congestions along the public streets adjacent to Bel-Air Village.
o    Accordingly, it was deemed necessary by the Municipality of Makati in the interest of the general public to open to traffic several village streets including Jupiter and Orbit streets.
·         Respondent’s claim: BAVA had agreed to the opening of Bel-Air Village streets and that the opening was demanded by public necessity and in the exercise of police power.
·         Petitioner’s counter-argument: It has never agreed on the opening of Jupiter and Orbit streets. By virtue of its ownership of the streets, it should not be deprived without due process of law and without just compensation.

ISSUES/HOLDING
a.       W/N the Mayor of Makati could have validly opened Jupiter and Orbit streets? – YES
b.       If yes, what is the nature of the state power being invoked by the Mayor? – POLICE POWER

RATIO
a. BAVA cannot rightfully complain that the Mayor of Makati, in opening up Jupiter and Orbit streets, had acted arbitrarily.
  • Citing Sangalang v. IAC, the Court held that Jupiter street lies as the boundary between Bel-Air Village and Ayala Corporation’s commercial section. Being considered as merely a boundary – and hence not part of Ayala’s real estate development projects – it cannot be said to have been for the exclusive benefit of Bel-Air Village residents.
  • The very Deed of Donation executed by Ayala Corp. covering Jupiter and Orbit Streets, amongst others, effectively required both passageways open to the general public.
o    “…the property will be used as a street for the use of the members of the DONEE (BAVA), their families, personnel, guests, domestic help and under certain reasonable conditions and restrictions, by the general public…”
  • As the Court asserted in Sangalang, the opening of Jupiter and Orbit streets was warranted by the demands of the common good, in terms of traffic decongestion and public convenience.

b. The act of the Mayor now challenged is in the concept of police power.
o    The demolition of the gates at Orbit and Jupiter streets does not amount to deprivation of property without due process of law or expropriation without just compensation – there is no taking of property involved.
o    Police power as the “state authority to enact legislation that may interfere with personal liberty or property in order to promote the general welfare.”
o    Even liberty itself, the greatest of all rights, is not unrestricted license to act accordingly to one’s will. It is subject to the far more overriding demands and requirements of the greater number.
o    Public welfare when clashing with the individual right to property should not be made to prevail through the state’s exercise of its police power.
o    The exercise of police power, however, may not be done arbitrarily or unreasonably. But the burden of showing that it is unjustified lies on the aggrieved party.
o    In the case at bar, BAVA has failed to show that the opening up of Orbit and Jupiter streets was unjustified or that the Mayor acted unreasonably.
o    The fact that the opening has led to the loss of privacy of BAVA residents is no argument against the Municipality’s effort to ease vehicular traffic in Makati. The duty of local executive is to take care of the needs of the greater number, in many cases at the expense, of the minority.


DISPOSITIVE: Motion for reconsideration by Bel-Air Village Association is DENIED with FINALITY. The petition in G.R. 60727 is GRANTED.